|

Variety,
January
21, 1921
The Kid (1921)
| The
Man |
Carl Miller |
 |
| The
Woman |
Edna Purviance |
| The
Kid |
Jackie
Coogan |
| The
Tramp |
Charlie
Chaplin |
| The
Policeman |
Tom Wilson |
Charlie Chaplin,
after a long absence, comes back in "The Kid". It is a
six-reeler, 5,300 feet long, and a corker. It will be called better
than "Shoulder Arms" or "A Dogs Life",
and is to be sent forth by Associated First National.
In this, the
longest subject he has ever released, Chaplin is less of the buffoon
and more of the actor, but his comedy is all there and there is
not a dull moment, once the comedian comes into the picture, which
is along about the middle of the first reel.
"The
Kid", for which a years labor is claimed by the distributors,
has all the earmarks of having been carefully thought out and painstakingly
directed, photographed and assembled. The cutting in some places,
amounts almost to genius. Introduced as a "picture with a smile
perhaps a tear", it proves itself just that. For while
it will move people to uproarious laughter and keep them in a state
of unceasing delight, it also will touch their hearts and win sympathy,
not only for the star, but for his leading woman, and little Jackie
Coogan.
It is almost
impossible to refrain from superlatives in referring to this child.
In the title role his acting is so smooth as to give him equal honors
with the star. Usually Chaplin is the picture, but in "The
Kid" he has to divide with the boy, whose character work probably
never has been equaled by a child artist. Edna Purviance is attractive
as the unmarried mother of the kid, but hers is comparatively a
small role.
Chaplin indulges
in the usual broad references where he handles a moist infant, and
rather overdoes it. Some of this play could be cut out to advantage,
and he might also eliminate the flash of the Savior bearing the
cross, a piece of symbolism flashed on the screen the emphasize
the burden of "the woman whose sin was motherhood", and
perhaps, to give the film tone.
Outside of these
two spots, the picture is flawless in treatment and has so many
good points, artistically and dramatically, it would seem the better
discretion if the cited spots, potential points of attack, were
discarded. The action is lightning-fast and the tempo never lags.
The picture,
as is to be expected, does not have its action in regal splendors,
but in tenements, police stations and back alleys. So there are
no "sets" to it. But the photography is sharp all the
way and the lightings, especially in the night scenes, are splendid.
There are characteristic
"Chaplin touches". A fine instance of imagination is where
he dreams of Heaven. His slum alley is transformed into a bit of
Paradise, with everybody including his Nemesis, the cop,
and a big bully who had wrecked a brick wall and bent a lamppost
swinging at Charlie turned into angels. Here, with Satan
doing a Tex Rickard, a cockfight between Charlie and the bully is
promoted and pulled off and feathers fly freely. At another point,
Charlie has "the kid"" an infant, in a hammock with an ingeniously
arranged coffee pot serving as a nursing bottle. Some of the best
business is here.
"The Kid"
starts with "the woman" issuing from a maternity hospital,
bearing her child in her arms. She is distraught and, after scribbling
a note, "please love and care for this orphan", abandons
the infant in a limousine. Auto thieves get away with the car, unaware
of the its cargo. They drive to the slum district, where a wail
attracts them to the child and they toss it in an alley. Charlie,
ragged but debonair, find the baby, and tries to get rid of it by
putting it in a perambulator with another. But the mother objects
and Charlie returns to leave it where he found it. A policeman makes
him change his mind. He then hands it to an old man, but the latter
drops it into the original perambulator. Chaplin is blamed and beaten
by the woman, and forced to take the child to his garret house.
Five years pass and the boy, devoted to his foster parent, is an
enthusiastic assistant in his business, which is glazing., The boy
breaks windows and Charlie, "happening" along at the psychological
moment, repairs them.
Meantime, the
mother of Jackie has risen to fame as an actress and when visiting
the slums, gives the boy a toy without knowing it is her lost child.
Subsequently, she holds the child in her arms after he has had a
fight and urges Charlie to get a doctor. The latter sends the county
authorities after the child, but they get him only after a terrific
battle in which little Jackie wields a sledge hammer with all the
delightful zest that Chaplin himself could have put into it. As
the boy is carried to a waiting auto truck, Charlie flees over roofs,
then drops into the truck and rescues the child. The doctor, who
has taken the identification slip from Charlie, is at the house
when the mother arrives. Seeing the note, she realizes Jackie is
her own boy, and puts a reward offer in the newspapers. This excites
the cupidity of the keeper of a lodging house where Charlie and
the boy are asleep. He steals the boy and takes him to the police
station, where the mother comes and claims him.
Chaplin wanders
all night seeking the boy in vain and returns to his slum, worn
out. It is then he has his dream of heaven. He is awakened by the
policeman, who takes him to the home of the actress, where Jackie
and his mother greet him and drag him into the house. This is the
end of the picture, the stars back being to the audience at
the fade-out.
Chaplin, in
his more serious phases, is a revelation, and his various bits of
laugh-making business the essence of originality. No better satire
has ever been offered by the comedian than the instruction of his
ragamuffin kid seated on a curbstone manicuring his nails, and his
instruction of the boy in table etiquet (sic) will register as one
of the best things he has done
copyright
© 1921 Variety
|